Commentary: English, staff can't be graded on one season
Football coach Ron English said he didn’t want the team to go down in infamy as a winless one.
But it happened Friday. Eastern Michigan University finished 0-12 – the ninth time in program history it’s gone without a win and the first since 1981 (0-11) – after a 28-21 loss at Akron.
How 0-12 happened
Opponent; score; time led
Army; L27-14; 0:00
Northwestern; L27-24; 0:00
Michigan; L45-17; 0:00
Temple; L24-12; 0:00
Central Michigan; L56-8; 0:00
Kent State; L28-6; 0:00
Ball State; L29-27; 37:21
Arkansas; L63-27; 0:00
Northern Illinois; L50-6; 0:00
Western Michigan; L35-14; 4:02
Toledo; L47-21; 0:00
Akron; L28-21; 0:00
Total: L459-197; 41:23
Ninth winless season in program history, first since 1981 (0-11).
Possibly related:
- Roger Federer captures fourth Cincinnati championship · Aug 22
- English addresses concerns for EMU football at MAC media preview day · Aug 2
- Americans stay strong in World Cup match · Jun 14
- Pirates draft EMU's Matt Skirving · Jun 14
- U.S. team chances slight in 2010 FIFA World Cup · Jun 7
The only other FBS school with a chance to go winless is Western Kentucky. It plays Arkansas State (3-8) on Thursday.
English and his staff will stay, as they should. One season, even one as atrocious as this, isn’t enough for any staff to turn around a historically losing program.
English has had the utmost support from athletic director Dr. Derrick Gragg from the day he was hired in December 2008.
The problems start with a defense that allowed 38 points and 427 (277 rushing) yards per game. Eric Lewis simply didn’t get the job done in his first year as a defensive coordinator.
Offensive coordinator Ken Karcher didn’t exactly whip together a prolific offense, either. The team averaged 16 points and 278 yards in the transition from a spread to a pro-style scheme.
Nevertheless, changing coordinators or other staff members won’t do much good this early in their tenure.
It’d retract from what the players have the learned. It was a steep curve, especially for those recruited by former coach Jeff Genyk.
The blame can’t all fall on the coaching staff, though. The players are the ones who are on the field, and even that was a rare occurrence.
The team was ravaged with injuries, which led to a lot of freshmen and underclassmen getting regular playing time – most notably freshman quarterback Alex Gillett. The experience gained will be valuable.
The lifeline of any program is recruiting, and that should improve a bit with the construction of a practice facility that’s expected to be completed in the spring.
Now is the time for English and his staff to make the best of what they have and try to sign decent players.
Needless to say, going winless isn’t acceptable if the administration truly wants to win. And if it continues early next year, expect a shorter leash.









by Carl Lumberg
The coaching was bad this year. Coach English had never led a team and it showed. Poor game management was evident all season and it got worse. The last game of the year, when the team was fighting to stay in it, and the plays came in so slow, EMU escaped two delay of game penalties (the referees were in error) and waisted a time out! THE LAST GAME OF THE YEAR and the coaches had yet to “learn” how to manage a game.
That is one example. Coach English came in with a lot of talk but the coaches failed as much as the players.
Next year, there is no execuse.
Flag for moderationby Judy
Give this new coaching team time to recruit. Ron English WILL have the ability to draw some good players into his program.
Flag for moderationThe coaching team is new. There WILL be some errors.
Mr English came into a program unable to recruit a 3rd stringer from Podunk. It will take some time for the new guys to get into the community and recruit. I am hoping we start seeing some good recruits from some local teams….Ypsi, Willow Run, Milan, Chelsea, Dexter A2, etc…..it’s a good way to attract a decent home crowd, following the kids that they KNOW from high school football.
And I’m tired of reading about our finest high school players locally heading out of state to play their college ball.
Just some thoughts….EMU is a great school. We are sometimes our own worst enemy. Stop talking yourselves down. Start talking EMU UP!!!
by Ralph
I’m betting that Gragg will not be around to fire English.
Flag for moderationby Donald
Ron English will need time to build a winning program. This takes time, if we see no improvement next season then it will be time for Ron English to go. That is what may happen to Rich Rod.
Flag for moderationby Carl Lumberg
People make lots of excuses when it comes to EMU! As an alum and season ticket holder, I dont make excuses.
Perhaps Coach English will build a program here.
I will “embrace the process” …
But the fact it, the coaches were in over their heads this year. I went to every home game. I went to the U-M game. I watched the Northwestern game on TV and I listened to every road game on WEMU …
The coaching was terrible.
They have had their “one” year; now they need to improve.
Flag for moderationby Judy
Mr Lumberg, I respect your opinion but think about this:
Two expert carpenters are given a detailed wood working job – one is given a hammer and chisel.One is given a toolbox full of artisan type woodworking tools.
In the end, the carpenter with the best tools produces the best product.
People rave about that carpenter.
They should be raving about the guy who bought that toolbox for him!
Recruiting is the name of the game. Mr English and company WILL recruit good players. I hope we get some local blood in here to draw more people to games. For the past 40 yrs I’ve thought EMU’s problem was trying to compete with UM crowds. I feel we should be crafting a hometown (meaning SE Michigan) feel to EMU football. Again, just my opinion.
Flag for moderationEnjoy your day!
Judy
by Carl Lumberg
Judy
Agree with everything you say – BUT – coaching is an issue that needs to be addressed. English even said so in the final pre-game talk on WEMU – that the coaches need to step it up.
Recruiting is a PART of the game … coaching is just an important.
They have had their year to learn; now there is no excuse for poor coaching …
Carl
Flag for moderationby Scapled Indian
To all of the comments.
You are all not seeing the truth.
EMU has been terrible for a long, long time.
With Jeff Genyk, EMU was really close to changing things.
Like, “Lost Huron” said, why did EMU not learn from Northern Illinois. The Huskies were in the exact same situation as EMU, except they were worse.
But that AD, and board of regents were smart enough to realize that more change would not help, and that while the results on the field weren’t there yet, they were close.
Coach Novak got an extension, and NIU has been one of the best MAC teams for the last 10 years. At one point being ranked as high as 11 in the AP poll.
Could you imagine EMU being ranked?
Experts thought that this year’s Eagles were going to be good, and they had their whole offense back from a team that broke 9 NCAA records its last 2 games.
The 2008 Eagles scored almost as many point in 2 weeks as the 2009 did all season.
We beat CMU last year and lost this year 56-8!!!!! 56-8!!!
Ron English did a terrible job this year. The kids played like they were in a coma. Not competitive, not tough, not winners.
EMU has made their own bed… I just feel sorry for those seniors.
Scalped
Flag for moderationby Kenneth Barna
I am a 1965 grad of Eastern and have always thought that I made the right choice of a university when I enrolled here.
Flag for moderationI was a thirty year season ticket holder from 1968 – 1998 because this was my university (not the one in Ann Arbor), and I felt this is where my loyalties should be. However, the almost constant losing season after season I dropped my season tickets. I have been to some games here and there throughout the last ten years or so, but again, mostly the same results.
I have visited both Central’s and Western’s stadiums for games in the past, and if your stadium qualifies for facilities then Eastern blows both of them away.
I do agree with most of what has been said on this site, but I feel that Eastern needs to win now – not three years down the line. Its been nothing but three years down the line for the last fifteen years!
I feel part of the problem is being in the shadow of Ann Arbor, and personally I believe we need to get into a better conference so we can attract better athletes. To me the MAC is mediocre at best. I also realize one has to offer a conference a competitive program of which we do not have at this time. In the last few years Eastern played Cincinnati (lost on a last second field goal try that missed), played Connecticut a few times and won once. My point is they are now members of the Big East and have very competitive programs in that conference. I also know it takes more than just joining a new conference, but I sure think that would help.